The Non-School Team of the Year Award dates back to 1974.

Year Team
2024 Fargo Force Hockey
2023 Minot State Men's Hockey
2022 University of Mary Men's Hockey
2021 University of Mary Men's Hockey
2020 Fargo Post 2 American Legion Baseball
2019 Minot State Hockey
2018 Fargo Force Hockey
2017 Minot State Hockey
2016 Bismarck Bobcats NAHL Hockey
2015 Bismarck Governors American Legion Baseball
2014 no award
2013 Minot State Club Hockey
2012 Mandan American Legion Baseball
2011 Casselton American Legion Baseball
2010 Bismarck Bobcats NAHL Hockey
2009 Dickinson American Legion Baseball
2008 Minot Vistas American Legion Baseball
2007 Minot American Legion Baseball
2006 West Fargo Fastpitch Softball
2005 Hope-Finley American Legion Baseball
2004 Dakota Wizards Basketball
2003 Thompson American Legion Baseball
2002 Minot American Legion Baseball
2001 Rick Tangedal rink, Williston & Edmore, curling
2000 Grand Forks American Legion Baseball
1999 Fargo-Moorhead Redhawks Baseball
1998 Bismarck American Legion Baseball
1997 Langdon Curling, U.S. and World Silver Broom Competition
1996 no award
1995 Minot Magic Edges Precision Skating (won national title)
1994 no award
1993 no award
1992 Mandan American Legion Baseball
1991 Tharaldson's Softball, Valley City
1990 Fargo American Legion Baseball
1989 Jan Lagasse Curling, Rolla
1988 NDSU Club Hockey
1987 no award
1986 Cavalier Junior Curling, Scott Brown rink
1985 no award
1984 Fargo American Legion Baseball
1983 Rolla Junior Curling
1982 Leonard Aalgaard Curling Rink, Grand Forks
1981 Bismarck GP Old Pro Basketball
1980 Wahpeton Chuck's Off-Sale Men's Slowpitch Softball
1979 Jamestown Hillview Softball
1978 Grand Forks Red Pepper Amateur Baseball
1977 Don Barcome, Jr., Curling Team, Grand Forks
1976 Minot Young America Softball
1975 Jamestown American Legion Baseball
1974 Bismarck Elks Softball