The College Female Team of the Year Award dates back to 1980. Prior to then, the Female Team of the Year was awarded to the top team among all levels of competition.
| Year | Team |
| 2024 (tie) |
Mayville State Basketball University of Mary Basketball |
| 2023 | University of Jamestown Volleyball |
| 2022 | University of Jamestown Volleyball |
| 2021 | University of Jamestown Volleyball |
| 2020 | University of Jamestown Volleyball |
| 2019 | Valley City State Softball |
| 2018 | University of Jamestown Basketball |
| 2017 | UND Volleyball |
| 2016 (tie) |
Dickinson State Softball University of Jamestown Basketball |
| 2015 | NDSU Softball |
| 2014 | UND Basketball |
| 2013 (tie) |
Williston State Basketball Minot State Softball |
| 2012 (tie) |
NDSU Softball UND Hockey |
| 2011 | NDSU Volleyball |
| 2010 | Minot State Softball |
| 2009 (tie) |
NDSU Softball Dickinson State Softball |
| 2008 | Dickinson State Softball |
| 2007 | Dickinson State Softball |
| 2006 | UND Basketball |
| 2005 | Lake Region State Basketball |
| 2004 | University of Mary Basketball |
| 2003 | NDSU Track |
| 2002 | NDSU Track |
| 2001 | Dickinson State Volleyball |
| 2000 | University of Mary Basketball |
| 1999 | UND Basketball |
| 1998 | UND Basketball |
| 1997 | UND Basketball |
| 1996 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1995 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1994 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1993 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1992 | NDSU Volleyball |
| 1991 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1990 | UND Basketball |
| 1989 | UND Swimming |
| 1988 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1987 | Lake Region Basketball |
| 1986 | NDSU Basketball |
| 1985 | UND Swimming |
| 1984 | UND Basketball |
| 1983 | Lake Region Community College Basketball |
| 1982 | University of Mary Basketball |
| 1981 | Minot State Gymnastics |
| 1980 | UND-Williston Basketball |